How much car can you actually afford?
The finance industry answers this question backwards — "what monthly payment are you comfortable with?" — because payments can be stretched until anything feels affordable. Here's the forward version.
The 20/4/10 rule
- 20% down — so you're never underwater from day one
- 4-year (48-month) loan — or 60 at most; if it needs 72–84 months, it's too much car (here's why)
- Total car costs under 10–15% of gross income — payment plus insurance, fuel, and maintenance, not payment alone
Earn $70,000? That's roughly $580–875/month for everything car-related — realistically a $350–550 payment once insurance and fuel take their share.
Backing into your max price
The calculator's affordability mode does this directly: enter the monthly payment you've budgeted, your APR and term, plus your down payment, and it solves for the maximum vehicle price. It's the same amortization formula run in reverse — no guessing.
The costs people forget
- Insurance — get a real quote for the specific model before buying; it varies wildly
- Sales tax and fees — often 7–10% on top of the sticker (trade-ins can reduce this)
- Depreciation — the biggest real cost of ownership, invisible until you sell
The uncomfortable truth
If the 20/4/10 version of your budget buys less car than you wanted — that's the point. The rule isn't measuring what a lender will approve (they'll approve much more); it's measuring what won't quietly eat the rest of your financial life.
FAQ
What percentage of income should a car payment be?
The payment alone: ideally 10% or less of gross monthly income. All car costs combined — payment, insurance, fuel, maintenance — under 15%.
Is the 20/4/10 rule realistic today?
It's harder with today's prices, which is informative in itself. If a car only works at 72–84 months with nothing down, the honest conclusion is usually a cheaper car, not a longer loan.
Should I include insurance in my car budget?
Absolutely — it's often $100–250+/month and varies enormously by model. Quote insurance on the specific car before you commit, not after.